Selected all your options? Now click here >>
25th Jun 2017 - We compare thousands of business and personal Leases every week. Our lease comparison website is handy, but if you can not find the vehicle that you are after, or want a more personal touch, call the CarLease247 team on 0333 4441 247
Quick contact

Used Car Rip Off in the UK

27 April, 2017

Julie Larkman

Another non-story by the Daily Mail off the back of some research by Confused.com

Used car sales people are apparently pressurising people into taking car finance at the time that they are in the dealership. Funny that. So, someone who is tasked with making a sale, tries to make a sale. Now, here is the thing. The point that is being made about this being “bad” is predicated on the idea that we consumers are vulnerable and more than a bit stupid.

If someone goes into a car dealer and signs a deal for a car at 12% APR, then that is entirely up to them. Now, they may or may not be aware that 12% is a high APR or indeed that they may be able to a get a much cheaper deal around the corner. But frankly, it is up to the customer at the end of the day and not some “big brother” authority telling businesses what they can or can’t do.

CAVEAT EMPTOR – Buyer beware. This is the case and always has been the case. It is our prerogative as consumers to shop around and get the best deal that we can for ourselves. BUT, it is also our right to strike a deal at any price we wish.

The concept laid out in the article would leave an American with their head shaking.

The only explanation for the need to “regulate” these scenarios is if we are indeed walking blind into the world of idleness, entitlement and vulnerability. The “Snowflake” generation if you will.

The article also seems to point out that charging 30% interest on a sub-prime loan is scandalous. This is indeed compared to the “financial crisis” by Baroness Altmann. Yet the article seems to bring in the idea of responsible lending as an issue. Seems entirely responsible to charge a higher rate of interest to a customer who presents a higher risk to the lender. The lender could, of course just tell the potential customer to do one and not lend them any money. Now THAT would be considered as discriminatory and no doubt there would be faux outrage that money lenders would not lend to someone who has a poor credit history.

So, a non-article really.

To come at this issue from slightly different angle. Let’s look at the stated APR of 9.4%. This is the number that the article is hung on. Is this so bad. Well, it depends. There are many ways in which company’s access money and then pass that on to consumers through loans and such like. They may be a large bank in which case their treasury rates would be very low. They might want to make a margin of (say) 4%. If the treasury rate was (say) 2%, the all-in output rate (that which the consumer will pay) would be 6%. Now if the customer did not have an exemplary credit history then the lender could do one of several things. They could put a charge over the vehicle. This means that they effectively own the vehicle until the debt is paid. If the customer defaults, they have the right (under Consumer Credit Act rules) to repossess the car. Even if the customer is not a bad lending risk, then the lender might still do this. The other option for lending to the bad-credit customer is to add an additional risk premium to the price. Let’s say they have a 20% chance of defaulting, the lender might want to add (say) 2%. So, we can easily get to 8%, not that far away from the “shocking” 9.4%. The best deal of 3.2% stated is no doubt conditional on other things and will only be available to the very best consumers from a credit perspective. Interesting how they don’t mention what the AVERAGE rate was?

Now let’s look at some things that are truly shocking: The average credit card interest rate in the UK is 15.74% as stated by Creditcards.com

Given that the UK Bank of England base (or Repo) rate is stagnating at around 0.25%, that is an ENORMOUS return. We appreciate that these companies probably cannot access treasury rates anywhere near the Bank of England base rate (they can), there are some organisations that lend money that do indeed have access to this very low rate – The Clearing Banks.

Now, the average UK variable rate mortgage interest rate is hovering around 4%. Given the base rate of 0.25%, this represents a gross margin of 1600%. Yes, you read that right – 1600%. Bankers may well chime in with technical reasons as to why that is not the case such as “thin capitalisation” rules or “arm’s length lending” or “term liquidity premiums”. I think you may well be able to explain a fair chunk of it away, but not 1600%

News feed

KIA Reveal Insane Stonic SUV Ahead of Autumn Launch

Posted on 7th June 2017 at 2:35 PM

Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicle Misuse for Company Cars

Posted on 12th May 2017 at 1:35 PM

Clean Air Zones Encourage Cleaner Vehicles

Posted on 5th May 2017 at 2:05 PM

New Car Sales Plummet 20 Percent in April

Posted on 4th May 2017 at 4:27 PM

Rubbernecking – Our Ghoulish Shame

Posted on 2nd May 2017 at 8:15 AM

Special deal
Business contract hire Honda CR-V, Estate
Honda CR-V Diesel Estate
1.6 i-DTEC SE Plus 5dr 2WD
£189.00 + VAT monthly rental
£1134.00 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.6 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire Honda CR-V, Estate
Honda CR-V Diesel Estate
1.6 i-DTEC SE Plus 5dr 2WD [Nav]
£201.16 + VAT monthly rental
£1206.96 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.6 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire Kia Optima, Estate
Kia Optima Diesel Sportswagon
1.7 CRDi ISG 2 5dr
£173.31 + VAT monthly rental
£1039.86 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 24 months
Rental profile: 6 + 23
Annual mileage: 10000
1.7 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire Volkswagen Scirocco, Coupe
Volkswagen Scirocco Coupe
1.4 TSI BlueMotion Tech GT 3dr
£188.80 + VAT monthly rental
£1699.20 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 24 months
Rental profile: 9 + 23
Annual mileage: 10000
1.4 litre Petrol Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire Volkswagen Scirocco, Coupe
Volkswagen Scirocco Coupe
1.4 TSI BlueMotion Tech GT 3dr
£175.19 + VAT monthly rental
£1576.71 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 9 + 35
Annual mileage: 10000
1.4 litre Petrol Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire BMW 1 Series, Hatchback
BMW 1 Series Diesel Hatchback
118d SE 5dr [Nav]
£211.00 + VAT monthly rental
£1266.00 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 6 + 35
Annual mileage: 8000
2 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire BMW 2 Series, Estate
BMW 2 Series Diesel Active Tourer
216d Sport 5dr [Nav]
£199.00 + VAT monthly rental
£1194.00 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 6 + 35
Annual mileage: 8000
1.5 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Special deal
Business contract hire Nissan Qashqai, Hatchback
Nissan Qashqai Diesel Hatchback
1.5 dCi N-Connecta 5dr
£188.31 + VAT monthly rental
£1129.86 + VAT initial rental
This vehicle is in stock
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 6 + 35
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Zetec [Nav] 5dr Auto
£263.99 + VAT monthly rental
£1583.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium 5dr Auto
£365.99 + VAT monthly rental
£2195.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 24 months
Rental profile: 6 + 23
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium 5dr Auto
£306.99 + VAT monthly rental
£1841.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 6 + 35
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium 5dr Auto
£278.99 + VAT monthly rental
£1673.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium X 5dr Auto
£384.99 + VAT monthly rental
£2309.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 24 months
Rental profile: 6 + 23
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium X 5dr Auto
£325.99 + VAT monthly rental
£1955.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 36 months
Rental profile: 6 + 35
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Ford Kuga, 4x4
Ford Kuga Estate
1.5 EcoBoost 182 Titanium X 5dr Auto
£295.99 + VAT monthly rental
£1775.94 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.5 litre Petrol Automatic
+ compare
Business contract hire Skoda Fabia, Hatchback
Skoda Fabia Diesel Hatchback
1.4 TDI SE 5dr
£164.46 + VAT monthly rental
£986.76 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1.4 litre Diesel Manual
+ compare
Business contract hire Skoda Fabia, Hatchback
Skoda Fabia Hatchback
1.0 MPI 60 S 5dr
£110.47 + VAT monthly rental
£662.82 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1 litre Petrol Manual
+ compare
Business contract hire Skoda Fabia, Hatchback
Skoda Fabia Hatchback
1.0 MPI SE 5dr
£136.47 + VAT monthly rental
£818.82 + VAT initial rental
Business contract hire
Contract term: 48 months
Rental profile: 6 + 47
Annual mileage: 10000
1 litre Petrol Manual
+ compare

Share this article Post this page to facebookTweet this pageGoogle+ this pagePost this page to LinkedinPin page

Posted on 27th April 2017 at 1:57 PM

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on this website. However, if you would like to, you can change your cookie settings at any time. Close this message.